Europe's spies and the Kazakh Trio, a Love Story, Part 2: Succession

Shukhrat Ibragimov, the third son of Alijan Ibragimov, had worked alongside his father as chosen successor since 2014. He now faces fragmentation among the founding Trio's heirs.

August 30, 2025 | Foreign Affairs

If at first you don’t succeed: How fake news manipulates US regulators

US court case exposes sinister manipulation of Maginitsky-related sanctions by a Kazakh oligarch in an attempt to steal Guatemalan mine from business rival.

ERG's succession war, part 3: Chodiev’s enemies begin to fight back

ERG's succession war, part 3: Chodiev’s enemies begin to fight back
Mounissa Chodieva

Following the death of Eurasian Resources Group (ERG) co-founder Alexander Machkevich, Patokh Chodiev is reportedly initiating plans to establish a succession strategy for the company.


ERG's succession war, part 2: behind the Black PR campaign, a well-honed network
Shukhrat Ibragimov

ERG's succession war, part 2: behind the Black PR campaign, a well-honed network

Speculation over the future of mining giant Eurasian Resources Group has run rife since one of its founders died in March.

Chodiev stills counts on GlobalSource's investigators

Patokh Chodiev is reportedly using US firm GlobalSource to navigate through his various ongoing anticorruption probes.


Chodiev stills counts on GlobalSource's investigators
GlobalSource corporate logo

Chodiev stills counts on GlobalSource's investigators

Patokh Chodiev is reportedly using US firm GlobalSource to navigate through his various ongoing anticorruption probes.

Kazakh justice ministry investigates law firm it often used
Night view towards Bayterek tower and House of Ministries in Astana Kazakhstan.

Kazakh justice ministry investigates law firm it often used

Astana is hoping to shed more light on the activities of Bolashak Consulting Group, a law firm which was often hired under former justice minister Marat Beketayev.

Tokayev adds final touches to domestic intelligence overhaul after spymaster ouster
Kazakhstan President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev

Tokayev adds final touches to domestic intelligence overhaul after spymaster ouster

The Kazakh president has managed to get several of his former intelligence chief Karim Massimov's allies to turn their coats as the reform of the country's domestic intelligence service, the KNB, nears completion.


London's business intelligence community braces itself for imminent leak
ENRC Corporate Logo

London's business intelligence community braces itself for imminent leak

A fresh wave of email hacks threatens to unleash a flood of sensitive information linked to the protracted ENRC saga, ensnaring lawyers, investigators, and journalists in a complex web of lawsuits and accusations.

Chodiev increasingly isolated by his former allies
Alijan Ihragimov

Chodiev increasingly isolated by his former allies

Kazakh oligarchs Alijan Ibragimov & Alexander Machkevitch are reportedly cooperating with investigations into their ERG partner Patokh Chodiev, amidst a bitter shareholder dispute involving accusations of bribery, fake news, and political manoeuvring.



Europe's spies and the Kazakh Trio, a Love Story, Part 2: Succession

Shukhrat Ibragimov, the third son of Alijan Ibragimov, had worked alongside his father as chosen successor since 2014. He now faces fragmentation among the founding Trio's heirs.

If at first you don’t succeed: How fake news manipulates US regulators

US court case exposes sinister manipulation of Maginitsky-related sanctions by a Kazakh oligarch in an attempt to steal Guatemalan mine from business rival.

Europe's spies and the Kazakh Trio, a Love Story, Part 1: Feeding an industry
Neil Gerrard

Europe's spies and the Kazakh Trio, a Love Story, Part 1: Feeding an industry

Kazakh trio’s long‑running, high‑budget espionage empire has repeatedly turned private intelligence into a corporate weapon.


Veteran investigator Charlie Carr pivots towards strategic PR work

Private spy Charles Carr has been briefing that he is pivoting his ‘business advisory firm’ C and F Partners, after two senior financial investigators fled the sinking ship.

Charles Carr pursues Europe expansion with support of Chodiev’s family office
Petra Vujnovic

Charles Carr pursues Europe expansion with support of Chodiev’s family office

Former K2 investigator Charles Carr’s expanding network of intelligence firms, backed by a controversial figure linked to ENRC, secures lucrative contracts across Europe and Africa.


Headlines


Europe's spies and the Kazakh Trio, a Love Story, Part 2: Succession

Shukhrat Ibragimov, the third son of Alijan Ibragimov, had worked alongside his father as chosen successor since 2014. He now faces fragmentation among the founding Trio's heirs.

If at first you don’t succeed: How fake news manipulates US regulators

US court case exposes sinister manipulation of Maginitsky-related sanctions by a Kazakh oligarch in an attempt to steal Guatemalan mine from business rival.

ERG's succession war, part 3: Chodiev’s enemies begin to fight back
Mounissa Chodieva

ERG's succession war, part 3: Chodiev’s enemies begin to fight back

Following the death of Eurasian Resources Group (ERG) co-founder Alexander Machkevich, Patokh Chodiev is reportedly initiating plans to establish a succession strategy for the company.


ERG's succession war, part 2: behind the Black PR campaign, a well-honed network
Shukhrat Ibragimov

ERG's succession war, part 2: behind the Black PR campaign, a well-honed network

Speculation over the future of mining giant Eurasian Resources Group has run rife since one of its founders died in March.

Chodiev stills counts on GlobalSource's investigators
GlobalSource corporate logo

Chodiev stills counts on GlobalSource's investigators

Patokh Chodiev is reportedly using US firm GlobalSource to navigate through his various ongoing anticorruption probes.

Europe's spies and the Kazakh Trio, a Love Story, Part 1: Feeding an industry
Neil Gerrard

Europe's spies and the Kazakh Trio, a Love Story, Part 1: Feeding an industry

Kazakh trio’s long‑running, high‑budget espionage empire has repeatedly turned private intelligence into a corporate weapon.